News

Other News

Choosing a lawyer is like buying a car

I’m by no means what people would describe as a car person however, after more than 10 years practising law, I have come to the conclusion that choosing a lawyer is a lot like buying a car.

Unfortunately, too many people buy the first car they see, without stopping to ask whether it’s the right fit for them and for the journey ahead.
For some people, their journey with the law is short. They have a discrete task, such as a simple will, a straightforward conveyance, or a letter that needs writing, and the matter resolves without court or drawn-out negotiations. For a trip like that, almost any reliable car will get you there.
For others, the road isn’t so straight or predictable. A family law dispute, a contested estate, a commercial falling-out or a criminal charge can stretch over months or even years, with twists nobody saw coming. On a journey like that, the car you choose matters a great deal.
Some people’s journeys are rougher still. The terrain changes constantly, from sealed road to gravel to mud, and the destination isn’t always clear from the start.

For these journeys you need something built for all conditions. An experienced, well-rounded lawyer is invaluable here. They know the main roads, but they also know the side tracks and the off-road dirt paths (negotiation, mediation, alternative dispute resolution, strategic settlement, and Court). Crucially, they can explain each route honestly and guide you safely along whichever one you choose.
Then there’s the sports car. The lawyer who charges an arm and a leg. It costs a pretty penny, it looks impressive, and you’ll turn heads as you drive past.

But in my experience, people who choose the sports car are rarely any happier at the end of the journey. A premium price doesn’t automatically mean a better outcome or a better experience. Sometimes you’re paying for the badge rather than the drive.
I recognise that a private lawyer isn’t always a financial option. For many people, government-funded legal services are the only way to get where they need to go.

I tend to think of them as the 50 cent bus. It’s affordable and it will generally get you to your destination, but you need to manage your expectations. The bus is often running late, it’s usually crowded, and it occasionally breaks down partway through the trip. None of that is the driver’s fault. These services are chronically stretched and the people working in them are doing their best with limited resources.
We’ve all done a long drive in a bad car. You arrive stiff and sore, drained and irritable, and the trip feels longer than it was. A legal matter is no different.

Very rarely do I see legal journeys without any potholes and the last thing you want is a car that breaks down the moment it hits one.
What you want is a car with good suspension, one that absorbs the shock, keeps you steady and keeps moving forward. In lawyer terms, that means someone who stays calm under pressure, anticipates problems before they arrive, and stays the course even when things get a little bumpy.

So how do you choose the right car? A few suggestions from someone who has seen plenty of people choose well, and plenty choose poorly. Start by thinking about the journey. Then take a test drive. Most lawyers offer an initial consultation. Use it. Notice whether they listen, whether they explain things in plain English, and whether you feel comfortable with them. You may end up spending a lot of time in this car.
Finally, check the service history. Experience in your particular area of law matters.

This article is for your information and interest only. It is not intended to be comprehensive, and it does not constitute and must not be relied on as legal advice. You must seek specific advice tailored to your circumstances.

Article authorised by Tim Ryan

Get in Touch