Further to our article previously published “The Australia Consumer Law and Recreational Vehicles” this article will cover the following issues which may arise: When you, the consumer, are required to reject the goods (in this article specifically motor vehicles or...
News
Other News
Granny flat arrangements: documenting a lifetime accommodation right and protecting an older person’s position if separation occurs

What this article covers:
- What is a “granny flat arrangement” (and what is a “granny flat interest”)
- Why “handshakes” fail: common risk factors
- Why wording matters (and what to avoid)
- How the Family Court treats granny flat arrangements if separation occurs
- Documenting consideration (and why it matters)
- What the cases show (illustrative only; outcomes are fact specific)
1. What is a “granny flat arrangement” (and what is a “granny flat interest”)
A granny flat arrangement commonly involves an older person transferring money or assets to a family member in exchange for a lifetime right to accommodation in a private residence.
In this article, for consistency:
- Arrangement means the overall family deal (money/assets contributed in exchange for lifetime accommodation).
- Granny flat interest (also referred to as a lifetime accommodation right) means the legal or equitable interest/right the older person is intended to receive as part of the arrangement.
A granny flat interest is typically limited by a life and may confer rights that are proprietary (not merely personal), such as rights of possession and occupation.
Those rights may be legal (capable of being registered on title) or equitable (for example, where the registered proprietor holds legal title on trust for the life tenant).
2. Why “handshakes” fail: common risk factors
The primary risk is that granny flat arrangements are often informal and/or poorly documented, which can leave the older person exposed if circumstances change.
Common ways these arrangements go wrong include:
- relationship breakdown and Family Court proceedings involving the homeowners;
- the older person having transferred assets and being left without significant assets;
- disputes about whether the transfer was a gift or consideration; and
- a lack of paperwork undermining enforceability.
These disputes arise frequently because older people may give away assets expecting a home and care, only for circumstances to change, leaving them without accommodation or resources to respond to the setback.
3. Why wording matters (and what to avoid)
In these arrangements, drafting can materially affect protection because the words used may influence whether the older person’s entitlement is characterised as a proprietary interest or merely a personal permission.
A right “to reside” or “to live” is typically framed as a personal right attached to the individual, whereas a right to “use and occupy” is broader and more akin to full use and enjoyment (potentially including the ability to let or rent).
Because the legal meaning turns on construction of the instrument, careful drafting is important if the intention is to evidence a granny flat interest that can be characterised as a legal or equitable interest (rather than a mere expectation).
4. How the Family Court treats granny flat arrangements if separation occurs
Granny flat arrangements can intersect with family law property settlement if the homeowners separate and property orders are sought.
Even if the home is in the adult child’s name, in property settlement proceedings the Court examines parties’ existing legal and equitable rights and liabilities, and has power to make orders altering interests, but must not do so unless satisfied it is just and equitable in all the circumstances.
As part of deciding what (if any) order should be made, the Court is to identify the parties’ existing legal and equitable rights in property and existing liabilities before considering contributions and current/future circumstances.
In practical terms, the older person’s protection in this context depends substantially on their ability to prove they hold a legal or equitable interest in the property (for example, a recognised life interest), rather than only an informal expectation.
5. Documenting consideration (and why it matters)
A core objective is to clarify and evidence a proprietary/enforceable right and to document that the older person acquired the lifetime accommodation right for valuable consideration, so the arrangement is capable of supporting recognised legal or equitable interests (or, failing that, strong evidence supporting equitable relief if the arrangement fails).
Documentation should therefore record both (a) the lifetime accommodation right (the granny flat interest) and (b) the consideration paid for that right, in a way that assists the older person to demonstrate an existing equitable or legal interest rather than a mere expectation.
6. What the cases show
Cases in this area illustrate that outcomes are fact specific, and that documentation and evidence of consideration can be significant in determining whether trust-based or other equitable relief is available.
For example, courts have refused relief where, on the evidence, no express, implied or constructive trust was established in respect of a “granny flat style” contribution (Wright v Wright & Adams (1997) 22 Fam LR 89).
By contrast, courts have treated it as unconscionable to characterise substantial funds provided by an elderly person as a non-refundable gift where the evidence showed the money was provided in expectation of being housed for life, supporting resulting trust-style relief (Field v Loh – [2007] QSC 350).
Even where a trust-based interest is arguable, interim protective steps (including maintaining a caveat) may turn on discretionary considerations such as balance of convenience (Barnard v Otten [2025] VSC 313).
If it goes wrong: immediate practical issues to anticipate
Where the arrangement is informal or unclear, disputes may arise about whether the older person’s contribution was intended as a gift or consideration for a lifetime accommodation right, and this can be amplified if the homeowners are involved in family law property proceedings.
Because interim protective steps (such as a caveat) can involve discretionary considerations (including balance of convenience), enforceability and preservation of position may not be straightforward even where an equitable interest is arguable.
Finally
If your family is considering (or already has) a granny flat agreement, early advice can help document the older person’s lifetime accommodation right and the valuable consideration paid in a way that supports recognised legal and equitable interests, particularly where family law property settlement issues may arise.
This article is for your information and interest only. It is not intended to be comprehensive, and it does not constitute and must not be relied on as legal advice. You must seek specific advice tailored to your circumstances.
Article authorised by Tim Ryan
Get in Touch
