消息

Other News

Gav Gasworks v JYP JIang – The Interpretation of Sunset Clauses

Recently, in the case CAV Gasworks v JYP Jiang [2026] the Queensland Court of Appeal had occasion to consider the interpretation of a “sunset date clause”, and more specifically whether the seller (the appellant) has exercised its right under that clause to terminate the contract validly.

Background

The facts of this case can be set out in fairly short compass.

Cav Gasworks Pty Ltd as Trustee for the Cav Gasworks Trust, (the Appellant) entered into a contract to sell 2 apartments (located at Newstead) “off-the-plan” to JYP Jiang Pty Ltd as trustee for the JYP Jiang Family Trust (the Respondent). The contract was dated 30 June 2017. The contract was subject to a “sunset clause” where Appellant was unable to give notice to the Respondent to settle the contract by the relevant “sunset date”, being the date that is 5.5 years from the contract date (i.e. 31 December 2022), either party may terminate the contract.

The plan of subdivision and the first community management statement to establish the scheme was registered on or about 28 October 2022 and 14 November 2022 respectively. However, the certificate of occupancy for the building/the apartments was not issued before the Sunset Date. The Appellant therefore withheld the issuing of the relevant notice to “call for” settlement and terminated the contract on 13 April 2023, some 4 months after the Sunset Date. The Appellant then entered into separate agreements to sell each of the lots to other persons subsequently. On 26 July 2024, the Respondent accepted this conduct as a repudiation of the contract by the Appellant and terminated the contract.

On 31 July 2024, the Respondent sued the Appellant for damages for breach of the contract. In the first instance, the primary judgement gave judgement in favour of the Respondent, the Appellant then appealed.

Relevant Clauses in the Contract

These following clauses in the contract are relevant in these proceedings (as considered by the court):

  1. The definition of “Completion Date”, as follows:

    “Completion Date: means the later of:
    (a) 14 days after the Seller gives written notice to the Buyer under clause 8; and
    (b) 30 days after the Contract Date

    provided that if a certificate of classification for the Building (or that relevant part of the Building) has not issued by the dates in (a) and (b), then the Completion Date is postponed until three Business Days after the Seller notifies the Buyer that a certificate of classification has issued.
  2. Clause 7, which relevant provides that:

    “7.1 Completion shall take place at Brisbane at a venue to be nominated by the Seller.
    7.2 Completion shall take place between 9.00am and 4.00pm on the Completion Date.
    7.3 On the Completion Date, the Buyer must:
    (a) pay the Seller without any deduction or retention except as authorised by this Contract:
    (i) the Purchase Price, less the Deposit paid by the Buyer; and
    (ii) any other money owing to the Seller under the Contract; and
    (b) deliver to the Seller an authority to release the Deposit.

    7.4 On the Completion Date, the Seller must give to the Buyer:
    (a) vacant possession of [the lots];
    (b) the Transfer Documents properly signed by the Seller (unless previously given pursuant to clause 6);
    (c) the Security Deposit, if any;
    (d) if requested by the Buyer, a copy of the certificate of currency for any policy of insurance required to be effected pursuant to the Act or the Module;
    (e) any certificate of title for [the lots];
    (f) a properly signed release (full or partial) of any mortgage or Security Interest[16] over [the lots] but the Buyer may not require the Seller to register the release or withdrawal before the Completion Date or to provide a discharge or release of any other Security Interest; and
    (g) all keys, access devices and codes for [the lots] (unless other arrangements have been agreed to).
    7.5 Provision of the items referred to in clause 7.4 shall be sufficient performance to transfer and discharge all of the Seller’s right, title and Interest to [the lots], the Chattels and Security Deposit.
  3. Clause 8 which relevant provides that:

    “8.1 The Seller must give the Buyer written notice after the Seller becomes aware that the Plan[10] and CMS[11] have registered, that the Scheme has been established and that a separate title for [the lots] has been created. The Seller need not give the notice under this clause until the Seller is satisfied that all obligations required to be performed by the Seller under this contract or at law on or before on or before settlement will be completed within 14 days of the notice given to the Buyer.

    8.2 The Completion Date must not be (and settlement must not take place) earlier than 14 days after the Seller gives advice by notice to the Buyer of the registration of the Plan, recording of the CMS and that the Scheme has been established or changed.
    8.3 If the Seller cannot give the Buyer such notice within 5.5 years after the Contract Date (or by any extended date as referred to in subclause 8.4) then the Buyer or the Seller may end the Contract by giving written notice to the other and the Deposit and any interest earned on it shall be refunded to the Buyer.
    …

Grounds of Appeal

The Appellant advanced two grounds of appeal, being:

  1. the Appellant contends that the primary judge erred in concluding that the Appellant did not lawfully terminate the contract pursuant to cl 8.3 of the contract on 13 April 2023; and
  2. By the second ground, the Appellant contends that the primary judge erred in concluding the Appellant could not exercise a right to terminate the contract pursuant to cl 13.1(c) of the contract after the “sunset date” for the contract.

In short, the court’s consideration focuses on the interpretation of the provisions in clause 8, especially the phrases “cannot” and “such notice” in the provisions of clause 8.

The appeal is allowed, and Crow and Hindman JJ gave judgement in favour of the Appellant while Bradley JA is in dissent.

Majority Reasoning

Each of the majority judgements is summarised as follows:

Crow J’s reasoning

In considering the first ground of appeal, (i.e. the proper construction of clauses 8.1 and 8.3 of the contract) Crow J notes that the provisions of clause 8 needs to be consider with clause 7 as a whole, as these provisions together provide for the settlement obligations of the Appellant and the Respondent under the contract.

In short, in Crow J’s judgement:

  1. The intent of the contract, is that on completion date under clause 7.4(a), the seller delivers to the buyer a fully completed lot as contracted for, with all of the items referred to in the schedule of finishes;
  2. The definition of Completion Date (which refers to the notice under clause 8) shows that the parties contemplated that there would be one written notice under clause 8. Accordingly, if a contract is not lawfully terminated by either party, the completion arrangements are triggered by a notice under clause 8. It is important to determine when such settlement notice must be “given”.
  3. The first sentence of clause 8.1 of the contract requires that notice to be given after the Appellant becomes aware that the plan and CMS have been registered, the scheme has been established and that a separate title for the lot has been created (hereafter referred to as the “Titling Conditions”). However, the this sentence does not state that such written settlement notice must be given immediately after those things occur.
  4. The proper interpretation of clause 8.1, from a reasonable businessperson’s perspective, is that the settlement notice, which must be given, but cannot be given until after the Title Conditions are fulfilled.
  5. It is expressly set out in the second sentence of clause 8.1 that seller need not give the notice under this clause until the Seller is satisfied that all obligations required to be performed by the Seller under this contract or at law on or before settlement will be completed within 14 days of the notice being given to the Buyer.
  6. It is a cogent legal requirement under the Building Act 1975 (Qld) that a building certifier gives certification that the building has been substantially completed and therefore the certificate of occupancy is issued before the building is occupied.
  7. Further, the certificate of classification for the building, may issue well before a building is nearing completion, and therefore well before the finishes to the lots are affixed, and the chattels could not practically be installed in the unit prior to the finishes. The completion of the finishes and the installation chattels is also requirements under the contract to achieve practical completion of the apartments.
  8. The interpretation, therefore, to be in the contemplation of reasonable businesspersons is that the completion notice under clause 8 should only be given when the seller has done all that is required to meet its obligations under the contract at the completion date, as provided in clause 7.
  9. reasonable businesspersons would have understood that there can only be one written notice under clause 8, which is required to be given by the seller only when the seller has done all that is required to meet its obligations under the contract and at law.
  10. the verb “cannot” in clause 8.3 ought to be construed as “cannot because the seller is unable to meet its obligations in clause 7.4”. That is, clause 8.1 requires the notice to be given by the seller when the seller is ready to settle, and not before the seller, acting reasonably and honestly, is ready to settle.
  11. Under clause 8.1, the seller is obliged to give the notice but not until the seller is in a position to complete all of its obligations under the contract or at law. The proper interpretation of the verb “cannot” in clause 8.3 then relates to the seller’s obligation in clause 8.1 to meet all of its obligations under the contract. As such, notice need not be given until that occurs, but must be given when that occurs.
  12. It is concluded seller could not give such notice before the sunset date, and that the right under clause 8.3 for the Appellant to terminate the contract is therefore enliven and the Appellant therefore validly terminated the contract. Thus the appeal was allowed.

As the appeal is allowed on ground 1, ground 2 of the appeal was only briefly considered.

Hindman J’s reasoning

Hindman J’s reasoning rests more on how a reasonable commercial person would interpret clause 8 (incorporating broader consideration to clause 8.4 and 9 in the contract), in that:

  1. Key to the interpretation of clause 8 rests on the words “cannot” and ”such notice”;
  2. The interpretation of the word “cannot” is connected to what may give rise to the Seller’s obligation to complete the contract. Thus the word “cannot” should be interpreted as creating an exemption to the seller’s obligation to give notice to complete the contract where the seller (acting reasonable) is satisfied that all conditions precedent to the completion of the contract have been met (and that the interpretation put forward by the buyer is artificial as “a person cannot at the same time be in a position they are obliged to do something and also need not do the same thing”), and
    a. the words “need not” in clause 8.1 shall be rightly interpreted as “is not obliged to”;
    b. the use of the word “after” in clause 8.1 also supports the construction that the second sentence in clause 8.1 intends to create an exception;
  3. an overall interpretation of clause 8.1 should be that, the second sentence of clause 8.1 creates a condition precedent (in a way) to the obligation to give notice (under clause 8.1).
  4. the notice(s) referred to in clauses 8.1 and 8.2 are one and the same notices, as:
    a. clause 8.2 partially reflect clause 8.1 and the provisions under section 212(2) of the Body Corporate and Community Management Act (1997) (the “BCCM Act”);
    b. the definition of completion date under the contract provides that it is “14 days after the Seller gives written notice to the Buyer under clause 8”, which implies that there is only 1 notice contemplated in clause 8.
  5. having regard to the provisions of clauses 8.4 (which provides that the seller may extend completion date due to construction related reasons) and 9 (which provides “subject to the terms of this Contract the Seller shall complete the Building and the Lot substantially in accordance with the Disclosure Plan and Specifications”, it can be inferred that whether the Seller is required to (“can”) give the notice under clause 8 to complete the contract is also depended on whether construction of the building/units is completed (among other factors).
  6. the seller’s submission regarding the purpose of clause 8.3 is preferred, in that:
    a. clause 8 is concerned with construction and completion of the building given it is what triggers completion;
    b. Construing the word “cannot” in a commercial, business-like way, the word must import with it some kind of actual, practical ability to do something beyond a mere bare ability or physical possibility regardless of the consequences. In that this should not be interpreted as the seller is required to serve a notice when there is no prospect of the seller being able to complete the building;
    c. the seller’s termination letter referred to the lack of a certificate of classification, is not instrumental to this case. By reading the statutory definition of that certificate, it becomes clear that the certificate being issued does not mean the second sentence of cl 8.1 has been satisfied. Many of the steps required for completion, as set out in the description of the lot in the disclosure statement, might remain incomplete despite the certificate having been issued.

Thus the Seller’s interpretation over the relevant contract clauses is preferred. As the appeal is allowed on ground 1, ground 2 of the appeal is unnecessary and only briefly considered.

Dissent

Bradley JA dissented in the case, and he prefers to disallow the appeal, in that

  1. clause 8.1 contemplates seller must give notice (and neither party may terminate the contract) if all titling conditions (i.e. the plan and the CMS have been registered, the Scheme has been established and a separate title for the lots has been created) are met. Under the definition of complete date, the lack of Certificate of Occupancy merely allows postponement of completion.
  2. Once the Titling Conditions are met, the seller must give notice under clause 8.1 (and the notices under clause 8.1 and 8.2 are the same “notice”). It can be inferred, from reading the definition of completion date (which provides that the completion date will be postponed where Certificate of Occupancy is not issued) together with clause 8, that the parties contemplate a clause 8.1 notice being given before a certificate of occupancy is issued.
  3. If clause 8.3 were interpreted to render the seller’ obligation to give notice to complete optional, it would be inconsistent with other parties with the contract, especially the clauses providing express rights for the seller to terminate the contract, as such circumstances to render the seller’s performance optional under clause 8.3 were not included in these other clauses giving the seller right to terminate.
  4. The Seller caused the plan and CMS to be registered on or about October and November 2024, and thus Seller became aware that the Titling Conditions were met. It therefore follows that neither party may rely on clause 8.3 to complete the contract (same interpretation applies when considering clause 13.1(c) for the purpose of ground 2 of the appeal).
  5. Thus Bradley JA prefers a narrower interpretation on clause 8 in that once the title conditions are satisfied, the seller is under an obligation to give notice to the buyer to complete the contract, and the right under clause 8.3 for the seller to terminate the contract is no longer exercisable.

Lesson for Drafters

It is clear that the court would, in interpreting the terms of a contract, view the contract as a whole and make with references to other parts of the contract. Thus, drafters must ensure that the provisions and the various parts of the contract are consistent and not cause contradiction to each other.

Further, needless to say, precise language should be use in drafting contract clauses, and where necessary definitions and appropriate sub-paragraphing should be used to keep the structure of the clauses logical and clear.

For example, clause 8 and the relevant definitions in the contract (subject of the judgement) could be re-written as follows:

  1. clause 8

    8.1 Settlement Date
    The Completion Date shall be 14 days after the day the Seller notifies the Buyer in writing that:
    (a) the Plan and CMS have been registered;
    (b) that the Scheme has been established; and
    (c) that a separate title for the lots has been created
    (the “Completion Notice”)
    provided however the Seller shall not be required to give the Completion Notice to the Buyer until the Seller is satisfied, in the Seller’s sole discretion, that all obligations required to be performed by the Seller under this Contract or at law have been fully performed.

    8.2 Sunset Date
    The parties further agree and acknowledge that the Sunset Date is the date this Contract provides for as a date by which Settlement must be effected for the purposes of section 217B of the Act, and:
    (a) If, other than because of the Buyer’s default, the Seller does not Complete this Contract before:
    (i). the Sunset Date; or
    (ii). if the Buyer requests a later date for settlement and the Seller agrees to the date, the later date,
    then, section 217B(2) of the Act allows the Buyer to terminate this Contract;
    or
    (b) if the Seller has not Completed this Contract by the Sunset Date because of the Buyer’s default (as referred to in section 217B of the Act), the Buyer will not have a termination right under section 217B(2) of the Act.
  1. Definitions
    The following definitions are inserted into the Contract:
    (a) “Act” means the Body Corporate and Community Management Act (1997);
    (b) “Completion Notice” means the written notice given by Seller under clause 8.1;
    (c) “Completion Date” means the date calculated under clause 34.1 as may be extended under this Contract.
    (d) “Sunset Date” means the date that is 5.5 years after the Buyer enters into this Contract, as referred to in section 217B of the Act.

We note:

  1. If the contract is also contemplated to be used after the establishment of the scheme, the completion date clause and definition could be further modified so that the completion date is the later of the date that is:
    a. 14 days from the date the Seller gives completion notice to the Buyer, or
    b. 30 days from the contract date.
  2. if the Sunset Date clause is re-written as above so that it is consistent with the provision of the BCCM Act. The right for the seller to terminate the contract is better dealt with the clause providing for the seller’s “preconditions” to complete the contract. An example of such clause could be:

    “In consideration of the Seller incurring (and continuing to incur) liabilities and expenses in connection with the undertaking of Development, the Buyer agrees the Seller may terminate this Contract by notice to the Buyer if:
    (1) the construction of:
    a. the building containing the Lot in general accordance with applicable approvals;
    b. the Lot in general accordance with the applicable approvals and with the Lot Finishes installed in the Lot;
    is not completed for any reason by the Sunse Date.
    (2) the Certificate of Occupancy is not issued for the building containing the Lot and/or the Lot for any reason by the Sunse Date
    …”

How We May Help

RMO Law can assist you in drafting the contract of sale documents, considering the terms of the contract of sale documents, and provide you with advice if you have any queries as to these documents or the terms within.

If you would like to discuss further, please reach out to set up a consultation with one of our lawyers to discuss.

This article is for your information and interest only. It is not intended to be comprehensive, and it does not constitute and must not be relied on as legal advice. You must seek specific advice tailored to your circumstances.

Article authorised by 罗利·奥雷根

Get in Touch